Alabama’s Secret
So after my last post on Alabama I thought I’d do a bit of research to see how Nick Saban creates such a great team. After a bit of poking around I found it.
Within the next month or two, Coach Saban will start recruiting new football players to take an athletic scholarship and come to play for the Crimson Tide. Come springtime, the returning players will start playing spring football. Then comes training in the summertime in preparation for the football season which starts in September.
So it all begins with recruiting and retaining the very best. Alabama plays in the SEC West, whose top three teams are currently ranked in the top five in the entire country. The SEC East is no slouch either, with teams like Florida, South Carolina, and Georgia to consider. Alabama must get the very best, train the hardest, and gel the strongest to achieve their goal of being a national champion. Even one mistake might cost them a title.
All that’s no big secret. The secret is at the other end of the season, when the games are all played and the trophies hoisted.
After the last game is played and all the players who are going pro have declared themselves eligible for the draft, Saban pulls all his assistant coaches and coordinators into a room. Once there, he requires the coaches to rank all of the remaining players in each class (Junior, Sophomore, etc.) from best to worst. A great debate ensues. The special teams coach might argue with the quarterback coach as to whether the punter is a higher performer than the backup quarterback. Or the offensive line coach might try to convince the defensive secondary coach that the right guard is more valuable than the strong safety.
And thus it goes, for hours or even days, until every player on the team in each class is ranked with respect to his teammates. Once the players are ranked, Saban then terminates the scholarships of the bottom 20% of the players, who are welcome to try to walk-on the following year or transfer to a different school and play for a different team. Saban then repeats this procedure with the assistant coaches and coordinators. He meticulously considers each coach and tries to decide if the linebacker coach is a better performer than the wide receiver coach. Once this is done, those in the bottom 10% are fired; the next lowest 10% are given a pay cut, and only the top 20% are given a pay raise.
Saban’s reasons are obvious, and every coach and player knows about this beforehand. They know that they are competing with each other for their spot on the team, for the right to not be terminated at the end of the year. They know that if they are to remain with the Crimson Tide, it will have to be at the expense of someone else on the team, and they will have to demonstrate higher individual performance than the others in order to stay.
What’s the result? It’s obvious. They abdicate their personal desires and goals and instead pull together to create a great, powerful, strong team, one without egos, one where team achievement is more important than personal achievement and personal stats are nothing compared to team victories.
Hmm.
Confused? You should be.
Of course, I’m making all that up. Whatever Saban does, it is surely not what I’ve just described. After going through all the effort to recruit the very best he can get, after working so hard to get the very best coaching staff he can find, and after expending so much to get all these different people to work together and create a national championship winning team, why in the world would he get rid of some number of lower performers as a matter of policy? Why would anyone compare the performance of two different people whose talents and abilities fit them for two completely distinct roles and insist that you have to decide which one is more valuable than the other?
Clearly you can’t build a strong team that way. Surely no person trying hard to create a strong, high-performing organization would take such an approach, right? I mean, come on. It’s ridiculous.