James Stewart – Master of the Crash
James Stewart has been referred to as the “Fastest Man on the Planet” (although that is pretty much just referring to the Supercross racing crowd – certainly anyone in a Bugatti Veyron is faster). But his 2011 season will be most remembered for crashes, not wins. In 18 main events this year, Stewart crashed in fully half of those main events and a total of eleven times (twice in a couple of races). It’s bad enough when you crash once out of every two times you race, but the real problem with James Stewart is that he frequently is taking someone else out along with himself.
I did some quick research on RacerX’s website last night, glancing over this year’s race reports. Here’s the list of people Stewart collided with in 2011 main events:
- Houston – Chad Reed, Justin Brayton, Chris Blose. Stewart came into the turn too hot, couldn’t make the turn, and plowed across the field, taking Chad Reed and the other listed riders out with him.
- Houston – Jason Thomas. Later in the main event, as Stewart was trying to make up ground, he jumped his bike right on to the back (literally) of Jason Thomas, taking Thomas out of the race.
- Atlanta – Chad Reed. With both competing for the win on the final lap, Chad Reed dove inside the leading Stewart in a 180 degree right hand turn, taking the line away. But Stewart tried to take the line anyway, and both Reed and Stewart went down. After the both got up, Stewart forgot about racing and tried to take Reed out again, but this plan backfired on Stewart as Reed found a way around for third. Stewart went from first to fourth on the final lap.
- Jacksonville – Michael Byrne, Matt Goerke. On the first lap of the main event coming into the first rhythm section, Stewart was, in my view, too committed to jumping through the rhythm section when he was bumped by Michael Byrne. Stewart shot clear across the track from the right to the left, collecting Matt Goerke in the process, taking them both out of the race. It seems like some other riders were also involved, but the race report doesn’t say for sure.
- Toronto – Ryan Villopoto. After a poor start by both Villopoto and Stewart, Stewart and Villopoto both got together in a 180 degree right hand turn, and both riders went down. This crash was oddly like the Reed/Stewart incident in Houston, yet it wasn’t on the last lap for the win, yet nobody was getting up in arms over Stewart’s “dirty riding” tactics for this one, unlike how things went for Reed. At least not yet.
- Dallas – Chad Reed. Stewart was trailing Reed coming into a whoops section. Stewart came through the whoops fast and eventually out of control, crashing into Reed in the turn at the end of the section. Reed was sent over the top of the berm and crashed onto the concrete. Stewart went on to take 4th.
- Las Vegas – Kevin Windham. Having taken the lead from Windham just laps ago but still under intense pressure by Windham, Stewart went into the whoops section, lost control, and crashed in the whoops right in front of Kevin (who, despite popular belief, was NOT following Stewart’s line through the whoops – Stewart crashed into Kevin’s line). It happened so quickly that Windham had nowhere to go other than to run right into Stewart’s bike. Both Stewart and Windham were out of the race.
These were in addition to his crashes in Los Angeles, Daytona, and Salt Lake City (twice) where he somehow managed to not hit anyone else.
So, Stewart crashed eleven times involving at least ten other riders besides himself, three of those times involving Chad Reed. It was odd that Reed was so criticized for his pass attempt for the win at Atlanta, in an agressive but legal move. Yet this pass only cost Stewart one position; Stewart’s stupid antics for the remainder of the last lap cost him more points and more positions than the crash with Reed. What people don’t remember is that Stewart also crashed into Reed on two other occasions, along with Villopoto, Windham, and others.
Somehow, when a rider under control makes an aggressive but legal move for the win and a crash ensues, that rider is a dirty rider, especially if the rider is Chad Reed and the rider being passed is James Stewart. But when a rider is riding out of control and crashes people out of the race, it is not dirty. I don’t get that.
It isn’t my intent to suggest that Stewart intentionally crashed into all those people. You don’t win a championship that way, and Stewart wants to win. It’s just that the guy rides out of control, assumes he can do whatever he wants, and cares so little for the safety of other people in the race that it doesn’t matter to him if he hits anyone else or not.
To make matters worse, of the ten other riders he crashed into this year, at least three of them — Thomas, Goerke, and Windham — paid a visit to the hospital as a result of their crash with Stewart. The first two had season-ending injuries, joining other riders like Ivan Tedesco and Chad Reed in the list of riders whose seasons have ended due to a collision with James Stewart.
All of this was in addition to his off-track problems. He was arrested in Florida for impersonating an officer when he used flashing red and blue lights to pull another vehicle over on a highway, a vehicle which just happened to contain off-duty policemen. Somehow, this felony arrest doesn’t merit any disciplinary action from the AMA, whereas Jason Lawrence got suspended for a year for his misdemeanor a couple of years ago.
I hate that Kevin Windham was racing so well in Vegas only to end the night at the hospital with internal bleeding. But in a way, I’m kinda glad it happened. Stewart rides without any respect for the safety of other riders on the track, and has done this for years. I can’t recall any other top rider who has had more collisions involving other riders — even Ricky Carmichael is among the list of riders who have been victims of Stewart’s wrecks. In the past this has seemed to get by without too much fan attention, but Kevin Windham is different. He’s the most adored rider in the whole paddock. And maybe, just maybe, this time it will incite enough ire from the fans to get the AMA to do something about it. I hope they do, because one of these times he might be ending someone’s career.

